We recently received an anonymous tip about some School District 11 (D11) buses that were sold for scrap. Over the years, we’ve received complaints about the 2017 mil levy in D11 that increased business and property taxes for all who reside within the district . Businesses, especially, saw a big jump in their taxes to help fund D11 schools.
In early May, D11’s transportation department staff drove approximately 30 buses with full tanks of diesel fuel to a scrapyard. Prior to the trip to the scrapper, D11 staff took cans of black spray paint to the buses. They painted over identifying information. Additionally, they blacked-out headlights and drew pictures on the sides of the buses. Windows were broken. These destructive actions make it apparent that the functioning vehicles were being thrown away, and there was no intention for them to ever be driven again.
What do we know about the buses? Quite a bit after filing a Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) request for more information. We know that the scrapyard paid D11 $600-1100 per bus. The scrapyard didn’t throw all the buses away, though. We know that 18 of the vehicles ended up for sale at a local used car lot. They are listed for over $11,000 each. The mileage of the buses we tracked down are between 180,000-220,000 miles each and range in year from 1998-2002.
We’ve also done a little research into the engines. They are Cummins and Mercedes Benz diesel engines that can often go up to 400,000 miles if maintained properly.
So, if they could be worth $11,000 each —or even more if they hadn’t been vandalized— why didn’t D11 just sell the buses to offset future expenses? Our math shows that if they had sold 30 buses at $11,000 each, the taxpayers of D11 would have $330,000 more in their school district budget.
As taxpayers, we have a big problem with this obvious vandalism and wastefulness.
We asked: Were the buses replaced with new buses or is there the intention to replace the scrapped buses with new ones in the future?
D11’s reply: “We purchase 5 new buses every year around September and October. This year we are purchasing 7 because of the new academic programs; the ridership and routes have increased.”
It makes a taxpayer wonder if the $330,000 would have made a nice down payment on 7 new buses.
We also asked for 2 years of repair records for the scrapyard buses. The maintenance records weren’t extensive. There were coolant leaks, heater repairs, radio repairs, squeaky brake repairs, and some seat repairs due to student graffiti damage. Nothing indicates the vehicles deserved a death sentence at the scrapyard.
There is a market for the buses, as evidenced by 18 of them ending up at a private used car lot. Private businesses saw the value of the vehicles. They saw an opportunity to profit. The public school district that collects tax dollars —also known as your money— did not see the value of the vehicles and threw them away. They can always just buy more buses —with our money.
This perfectly illustrates the point that private businesses understand the value of a dollar, but government entities don’t. It’s easy come, easy go with our tax dollars.
Do you live in COS School District 11? Are you as ticked off as we are that $330,000 of your tax dollars just went down the tubes? Do you want to know if this is a common practice with older D11 vehicles? Your elected school board members and public servants should hear from you. The School Board member email addresses listed below:
Shawn Gullixson- Shawn.Gullixson@d11.org
Julie Ott- firstname.lastname@example.org
Jim Mason- email@example.com
Parth Melpakam- firstname.lastname@example.org
Darleen Daniels- email@example.com
Jason Jorgenson- firstname.lastname@example.org
Chris Wallis- email@example.com
Also, consider contacting D11’s School Superintendent Michael Thomas and share your thoughts with him at Michael.Thomas@d11.org .
Typical fraud waste and abuse from a government entity! Why wasn’t one of the ridiculously high paid D11 employees tasked to sell these vehicles? D11 has socalled educated staff running it but it seems there is no work ethic from any D11 staff members. Whoever scrapped these newer buses should be fired!
Occasionally there are regulations created by the CDE that generate this waste sometimes the service life of a vehicle is ended on a technicality that does not affect the private sector. However it is very frustrating to not maximize every tax dollar I have worked for government entities before and negotiating a private sale for maximum dollars is sometimes prevented by financial regulation which is really foolish. I’ve experienced situations where useless material to the government entity could have negotiated sale for 6,000 times the price that it auctioned for. But the only way to dispose of it was by auction legally. There’s definitely a maze of checks and balances that aren’t well thought out that Force waste and abuse a good place to start with reform as to look at how the laws and rules interact with each other.
These buses still had a lot of life in them. Seeing that the maintenance in all of them was pretty minor this sickens me. Shy would they have the buses vandalized? So many good parts. Small school districts would love to have had these buses. I refuse to vote for any bonds for D-11. When I worked there I was a single parent. I loved the raises we got. How ever the raises were supposed to go to the kids and teachers. Not the support staff and admin.
Shame on whoever was in charge of this stupid move.